Skip to content
https://project-syndicate.org

Performance

· 17 checks — Lighthouse + waterfall + sustainability rolled into one auditable list.
SCORE
74
GRADE
C
FIX
6
REVIEW
2
PASS
7
INFO
2

Performance-focused optimization plan with CWV assessment, top offenders, and time estimates

Mobile Desktop
40
Performance Overall performance score (0–100) based on Core Web Vitals and other metrics. 90+ is good.
89
Accessibility Measures how accessible the page is for users with disabilities. Checks color contrast, ARIA labels, and semantic HTML.
81
Best Practices Checks for modern web development best practices including HTTPS, no console errors, and secure JavaScript.
82
SEO Measures basic SEO optimizations: meta tags, crawlability, link text, and mobile friendliness.

First Contentful Paint First Contentful Paint — how long until the browser renders the first piece of content. Under 1.8s is good.

2.39 s

Largest Contentful Paint Largest Contentful Paint — how long until the largest visible element loads. Under 2.5s is good.

14.37 s

Total Blocking Time Total Blocking Time — total time the main thread was blocked, preventing user input. Under 200ms is good.

700 ms

Cumulative Layout Shift Cumulative Layout Shift — measures visual stability. How much the page layout shifts during loading. Under 0.1 is good.

0.241

Speed Index Speed Index — how quickly content is visually displayed during load. Under 3.4s is good.

4.48 s

Time to Interactive Time to Interactive — how long until the page is fully interactive and responds to user input. Under 3.8s is good.

17.08 s

Page Load Progression

375 ms
750 ms
1.1 s
1.5 s
1.9 s
2.2 s
2.6 s
3.0 s
Checks
17
7 PASS 2 REVIEW 6 FIX
F
Page Weight Budget
Action
3.0 MB transferred, 72 requests
FIX
3.0 MB transferred, 72 requests
Warning::
Page weighs 5.6 MB (3.0 MB transferred)
Warning::
Images are 1.2 MB — compress or use modern formats
Convert images to WebP/AVIF and resize to display dimensions to reduce transfer size.
Got: 1.2 MB
Warning::
JavaScript is 1.0 MB — consider code splitting or lazy loading
Large JavaScript bundles delay interactivity. Split code by route or defer non-critical scripts.
Got: 1.0 MB
Info::
Fonts are 302 KB — consider subsetting or using system fonts
Subset fonts to include only used characters, or switch to system font stacks.
Got: 302 KB
Info::
72 HTTP requests
Info::
Estimated 0.63 g CO2 per page load
3.0 MB / 2.4 MB budget
3.0 MB transferred
72 requests
0.63 g CO2 per page load
Images 1.2 MiB 39%
JavaScript 1.0 MiB 33%
Other 309.2 KiB 10%
Fonts 301.7 KiB 10%
HTML 152.5 KiB 5%
CSS 57.9 KiB 2%
Other 22.6 KiB 1%
Other 2.5 KiB 0%
Other 1.0 KiB 0%
Other 565 B 0%
Other 0 B 0%
0 2.4 MB 4.9 MB
Over budget

Convert images to WebP/AVIF and resize to display dimensions to reduce transfer size.

Why this matters

Image bandwidth is high — modern formats (WebP/AVIF) and resizing typically cut it 50%+.

Source: web.dev

Large JavaScript bundles delay interactivity. Split code by route or defer non-critical scripts.

Why this matters

JavaScript bundle is large — code-split routes and lazy-load off-screen components to defer.

Source: web.dev

Subset fonts to include only used characters, or switch to system font stacks.

Why this matters

Font payload is large — subset to used glyphs only, or fall back to system fonts (zero load time).

Source: web.dev font loading

D
Third-Party Impact
Action
100% third-party, 0 ms blocking
FIX
100% third-party, 0 ms blocking
Warning::
Third-party code accounts for 100% of page weight (3.0 MiB of 3.0 MiB)
Info::
Third-party blocking time is low (0 ms)
100%
First-party Third-party
D
JS Execution Cost
Action
2708ms total JS execution
FIX
2708ms total JS execution
Warning::
https://www.project-syndicate.org/: 655ms CPU time
Warning::
Unattributable: 305ms CPU time
Warning::
https://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquery/3.7.1...: 300ms CPU time
Info::
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-D51Y...: 226ms CPU time
Info::
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/destination?...: 222ms CPU time
Warning::
Third-party scripts: 2708ms (100% of total)

Main Thread Breakdown

Script Evaluation 54% Other 17% Style & Layout 16% Script Parsing & Compilation 8%
ScriptTotalScriptingParse/CompileParty
https://www.project-syndicate.org/655ms26ms4ms3rd
Unattributable305ms12ms0ms3rd
https://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquery/3.7.1/jquery.min.js300ms183ms7ms3rd
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-D51YBBGJVH&cx=c&gtm=4e64k0226ms190ms34ms3rd
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/destination?id=G-6MFMGV4H84&cx=c&gtm=4e64k0222ms183ms37ms3rd
https://scripts.clarity.ms/0.8.59/clarity.js207ms185ms8ms3rd
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=GTM-N6JW4VM189ms147ms40ms3rd
https://cc.cdn.civiccomputing.com/9/cookieControl-9.x.min.js188ms154ms32ms3rd
https://www.project-syndicate.org/scripts/application.min.js?v=2bvm9WaCIHJtuJBpuDo6TcH9HjIGBjrjSuZ0tdFF_P8164ms86ms32ms3rd
https://script.hotjar.com/modules.6a0f3932cb1341a35c18.js147ms127ms17ms3rd

Showing top 10 of 11 scripts

D
JS Bundles
Action
23 scripts, 461 KB unused
FIX
23 scripts, 461 KB unused
Warning::
https://www.project-syndicate.org/scripts/applicat...: 119 KB unused (75%)
Consider code splitting or tree shaking to reduce unused code.
Warning::
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=GTM-N6J...: 85 KB unused (53%)
Consider code splitting or tree shaking to reduce unused code.
Warning::
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/destination?...: 71 KB unused (42%)
Consider code splitting or tree shaking to reduce unused code.
Warning::
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-D51Y...: 64 KB unused (41%)
Consider code splitting or tree shaking to reduce unused code.
Warning::
https://cc.cdn.civiccomputing.com/9/cookieControl-...: 58 KB unused (47%)
Consider code splitting or tree shaking to reduce unused code.
Info::
Total unused JavaScript: 461 KB
461 KB unused JavaScript

Downloaded but never executed on this page.

ScriptSizeUnusedMinifiedParty
https://www.project-syndicate.org/scripts/application.min.js?v=2bvm9WaCIHJtuJBpuDo6TcH9HjIGBjrjSuZ0tdFF_P8160 KB119 KB (75%)✓3rd
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=GTM-N6JW4VM159 KB85 KB (53%)✓3rd
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/destination?id=G-6MFMGV4H84&cx=c&gtm=4e64k0171 KB71 KB (42%)✓3rd
https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-D51YBBGJVH&cx=c&gtm=4e64k0157 KB64 KB (41%)✓3rd
https://cc.cdn.civiccomputing.com/9/cookieControl-9.x.min.js123 KB58 KB (47%)✓3rd
https://script.hotjar.com/modules.6a0f3932cb1341a35c18.js57 KB38 KB (67%)✓3rd
https://assets.poool.fr/access.min.js31 KB26 KB (85%)✓3rd
https://www.clarity.ms/tag/tkf8ndlyjc?ref=gtm1 KB—✓3rd
https://data.flw.li/piwik/piwik.js22 KB—✓3rd
https://static.hotjar.com/c/hotjar-6508368.js?sv=76 KB—✓3rd

Consider code splitting or tree shaking to reduce unused code.

Why this matters

This bundle has high unused code — code-split or tree-shake to ship only what executes.

Source: web.dev / Lighthouse coverage

Consider code splitting or tree shaking to reduce unused code.

Why this matters

This bundle has high unused code — code-split or tree-shake to ship only what executes.

Source: web.dev / Lighthouse coverage

Consider code splitting or tree shaking to reduce unused code.

Why this matters

This bundle has high unused code — code-split or tree-shake to ship only what executes.

Source: web.dev / Lighthouse coverage

Consider code splitting or tree shaking to reduce unused code.

Why this matters

This bundle has high unused code — code-split or tree-shake to ship only what executes.

Source: web.dev / Lighthouse coverage

Consider code splitting or tree shaking to reduce unused code.

Why this matters

This bundle has high unused code — code-split or tree-shake to ship only what executes.

Source: web.dev / Lighthouse coverage

F
Page Weight Inventory
Action
72 resources · 3.0 MB · 461 KB savings available
FIX
72 resources · 3.0 MB · 461 KB savings available
Warning::
Page weight 2.0 MB over 1MB target
Got: 3.0 MB Expected: ≤ 1 MB
Info::
~461 KB of savings available
Warning::
71 third-party resources (100% of weight)
Info::
2 resources over 200KB
72 resources · 3.0 MiB · 71 third-party 2.0 MiB over 1MB target
Image 40% · 1.2 MiB
JavaScript 33% · 1.0 MiB
Other 10% · 313.7 KiB
Font 10% · 301.7 KiB
Document 5% · 152.5 KiB
CSS 2% · 57.9 KiB

~460.9 KiB of savings available

Remove unused JavaScript: 460.9 KiB
F
HTTP Caching
Action
No cache headers
FIX
No cache headers
Warning::
No Cache-Control header found
Browsers will use heuristic caching, which can be unpredictable. Set explicit cache headers.

No Cache-Control header

Adding a Cache-Control header can significantly improve repeat-visit performance.

B
Image Optimization
19 images, 0 KB saveable
REVIEW
19 images, 0 KB saveable
Warning::
https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/a6fde... is missing width/height — may cause layout shift
Set explicit width and height to prevent CLS.
19 images 1.2 MB
0 oversized -0 KB
19 legacy format
1 missing dimensions CLS risk

Set explicit width and height to prevent CLS.

Why this matters

Image without explicit width/height — browser can't reserve space; CLS jumps when image loads.

Source: web.dev / Core Web Vitals

C
Green Hosting
Action
Whether the site is served from green-energy infrastructure
REVIEW

Green Hosting

No green hosting detected

A+
Text Compression
All text resources are compressed
PASS
All text resources are compressed
Info::
All text resources are compressed
All text resources are properly compressed.
A+
Font Loading
5 fonts (302 KB)
PASS
5 fonts (302 KB)
Info::
5 font(s) use font-display: swap (FOUT risk but functional)

Web fonts

5

302 KB total

Render-blocking

0

of 5

Dominant font-display

swap

Most common across fonts

Font loading timeline
Transfer FOIT (block) FOUT (swap)
0 ms 2.0 s 4.0 s 6.0 s 8.0 s 10.0 s 12.0 s 14.0 s FCP 2.4 s LCP 14.4 shttps://www.project-syndicate.org/fonts/1/bold.woff2bold.woff2 https://www.project-syndicate.org/fonts/1/bold.woff2 — 19.6 KiB — 46 ms — font-display: swaphttps://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notosans/v42/o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ryti20_6n1iPHjc5a7du3mhPy0.woff2o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ry... https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notosans/v42/o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ryti20_6n1iPHjc5a7du3mhPy0.woff2 — 35.0 KiB — 73 ms — font-display: swaphttps://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notoserif/v33/ga6daw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNVls-hfgvz8JcMofYTYf6D33WsNFH.woff2ga6daw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNVls... https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notoserif/v33/ga6daw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNVls-hfgvz8JcMofYTYf6D33WsNFH.woff2 — 35.9 KiB — 65 ms — font-display: swaphttps://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notosans/v42/o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ryti20_6n1iPHjc5aDdu3mhPy1Fig.woff2o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ry... https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notosans/v42/o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ryti20_6n1iPHjc5aDdu3mhPy1Fig.woff2 — 164.3 KiB — 95 ms — font-display: swaphttps://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notoserif/v33/ga6faw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNfFIMZhhWnFTyNZIQD1-_P3_ct_NFiQg.woff2ga6faw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNfFI... https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notoserif/v33/ga6faw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNfFIMZhhWnFTyNZIQD1-_P3_ct_NFiQg.woff2 — 46.9 KiB — 77 ms — font-display: swap
bold.woff2 woff2 swap
Size 20 KB
Load time 46 ms
Start 293 ms
Risk FOUT — text flashes from fallback to web font
o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ry... woff2 swap
Size 35 KB
Load time 73 ms
Start 594 ms
Risk FOUT — text flashes from fallback to web font
ga6daw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNVls... woff2 swap
Size 36 KB
Load time 65 ms
Start 595 ms
Risk FOUT — text flashes from fallback to web font
o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ry... woff2 swap
Size 164 KB
Load time 95 ms
Start 595 ms
Risk FOUT — text flashes from fallback to web font
  • Subset this font — over 100 KB suggests Latin Extended or full glyph coverage that most pages don't need
ga6faw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNfFI... woff2 swap
Size 47 KB
Load time 77 ms
Start 595 ms
Risk FOUT — text flashes from fallback to web font
Optimization checklist
  • Preload critical fonts (priority=high)
  • Use woff2 format for all fonts
  • Set font-display to swap, optional, or fallback
  • Subset large fonts (≤100 KB each)

Fixing the unchecked items could save ~82 KB and ~164 ms

A+
Resource Caching
All resources properly cached
PASS
All resources properly cached
Info::
No caching issues found
All static resources have appropriate caching headers.
A+
Critical Rendering Path
No render-blocking resources
PASS
No render-blocking resources
Info::
No render-blocking resources detected
A+
Resource Hints
7 hints, 0 missing preconnects
PASS
7 hints, 0 missing preconnects
Info::
Page uses 7 resource hint(s)

Current Resource Hints

preconnect
3
preload
1
dns-prefetch
3
prefetch
—

7 resource hints configured

A+
Render-Blocking Resources
No render-blocking resources detected
PASS
No render-blocking resources detected
Info::
No render-blocking resources detected in <head>
A+
Third-Party Resources
No third-party resources detected
PASS
No third-party resources detected
Network Waterfall
72 requests over 2635ms
INFO
0 ms 2.0 s 4.0 s 6.0 s 8.0 s 10.0 s 12.0 s 14.0 s FCP 2.4 s LCP 14.4 shttps://project-syndicate.org// https://project-syndicate.org/ — 301 — 161 B — 126 ms — http/1.1https://www.project-syndicate.org/www.project-syndicate.org/ https://www.project-syndicate.org/ — 200 — 55.4 KiB — 210 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/fonts/1/bold.woff2www.project-syndicate.org/fonts/1/b... https://www.project-syndicate.org/fonts/1/bold.woff2 — 200 — 19.6 KiB — 46 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/css/styles.min.css?v=tHx_zKUaEooV4cYyQnbVvI8_6IhtqKkvz3C52suXTv8www.project-syndicate.org/css/style... https://www.project-syndicate.org/css/styles.min.css?v=tHx_zKUaEooV4cYyQnbVvI8_6IhtqKkvz3C52suXTv8 — 200 — 50.9 KiB — 69 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/favicon/manifest.jsonwww.project-syndicate.org/favicon/m... https://www.project-syndicate.org/favicon/manifest.json — 200 — 1.0 KiB — 411 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/54948d9326c5ff7801ec2094560c7dd1.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/54948d9326c5ff7801ec2094560c7dd1.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 78.4 KiB — 161 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/746e81c081b2a506fffdc14c127e5b27.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/746e81c081b2a506fffdc14c127e5b27.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 99.3 KiB — 103 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/bec80f6e77af9b412b478c14c6f45c2e.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/bec80f6e77af9b412b478c14c6f45c2e.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 109.5 KiB — 102 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/5e7d4080cf183402724539f1b21a57cd.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/5e7d4080cf183402724539f1b21a57cd.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 94.6 KiB — 132 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/df7b3af0c72e9a2e3163ebc5ae5694d5.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/df7b3af0c72e9a2e3163ebc5ae5694d5.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 128.4 KiB — 114 ms — h2https://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquery/3.7.1/jquery.min.jsajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquer... https://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquery/3.7.1/jquery.min.js — 200 — 30.4 KiB — 116 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/scripts/application.min.js?v=2bvm9WaCIHJtuJBpuDo6TcH9HjIGBjrjSuZ0tdFF_P8www.project-syndicate.org/scripts/a... https://www.project-syndicate.org/scripts/application.min.js?v=2bvm9WaCIHJtuJBpuDo6TcH9HjIGBjrjSuZ0tdFF_P8 — 200 — 159.8 KiB — 72 ms — h2https://assets.poool.fr/access.min.jsassets.poool.fr/access.min.js https://assets.poool.fr/access.min.js — 200 — 31.3 KiB — 101 ms — h2https://assets.poool.fr/audit.min.jsassets.poool.fr/audit.min.js https://assets.poool.fr/audit.min.js — 200 — 15.1 KiB — 96 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/f5d89e319df6fcbb807d94727f98b929.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/f5d89e319df6fcbb807d94727f98b929.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 60.1 KiB — 125 ms — h2https://data.flw.li/piwik/piwik.jsdata.flw.li/piwik/piwik.js https://data.flw.li/piwik/piwik.js — 200 — 21.6 KiB — 114 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/css/print.min.css?v=K59KUm2uuIRa1YCAwpEtbOVk2AdK-aVwwH1Ya90MYRMwww.project-syndicate.org/css/print... https://www.project-syndicate.org/css/print.min.css?v=K59KUm2uuIRa1YCAwpEtbOVk2AdK-aVwwH1Ya90MYRM — 200 — 5.1 KiB — 41 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/sprite.symbol.svgwww.project-syndicate.org/images/sp... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/sprite.symbol.svg — 200 — 7.4 KiB — 39 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/ps_logo.svgwww.project-syndicate.org/images/ps... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/ps_logo.svg — 200 — 1.1 KiB — 58 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/PScream.pngwww.project-syndicate.org/images/PS... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/PScream.png — 200 — 11.2 KiB — 60 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/PSblack.pngwww.project-syndicate.org/images/PS... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/PSblack.png — 200 — 9.4 KiB — 93 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/sprite.css.svg?v=ub0dxcuwww.project-syndicate.org/images/sp... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/sprite.css.svg?v=ub0dxcu — 200 — 9.0 KiB — 87 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/75e6ba362294f57645e6e4f3a099476a.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/75e6ba362294f57645e6e4f3a099476a.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 115.8 KiB — 62 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/b598b22bbd89d5d119fdb7654d48efba.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/b598b22bbd89d5d119fdb7654d48efba.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 46.0 KiB — 64 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/7a204d35b82eb950d5ce0f1646326f21.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/7a204d35b82eb950d5ce0f1646326f21.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 144.2 KiB — 67 ms — h2https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=GTM-N6JW4VMwww.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=... https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=GTM-N6JW4VM — 200 — 159.1 KiB — 184 ms — h2https://js.monitor.azure.com/scripts/b/ai.2.min.jsjs.monitor.azure.com/scripts/b/ai.2... https://js.monitor.azure.com/scripts/b/ai.2.min.js — 200 — 46.2 KiB — 138 ms — h2https://www1.project-syndicate.org/fwat.js?v=2026-4-22&s=1www1.project-syndicate.org/fwat.js?... https://www1.project-syndicate.org/fwat.js?v=2026-4-22&s=1 — 200 — 2.2 KiB — 53 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/ff97447608e6eeb1e7495525e2cfaebb.4-3-large.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/ff97447608e6eeb1e7495525e2cfaebb.4-3-large.1.jpg — 200 — 48.1 KiB — 45 ms — h2https://fonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Noto+Sans:400,700|Noto+Serif:400,400i,700,700i&display=swapfonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Not... https://fonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Noto+Sans:400,700|Noto+Serif:400,400i,700,700i&display=swap — 200 — 1.9 KiB — 95 ms — h2
0 ms 2.0 s 4.0 s 6.0 s 8.0 s 10.0 s 12.0 s 14.0 s FCP 2.4 s LCP 14.4 shttps://project-syndicate.org// https://project-syndicate.org/ — 301 — 161 B — 126 ms — http/1.1https://www.project-syndicate.org/www.project-syndicate.org/ https://www.project-syndicate.org/ — 200 — 55.4 KiB — 210 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/fonts/1/bold.woff2www.project-syndicate.org/fonts/1/b... https://www.project-syndicate.org/fonts/1/bold.woff2 — 200 — 19.6 KiB — 46 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/css/styles.min.css?v=tHx_zKUaEooV4cYyQnbVvI8_6IhtqKkvz3C52suXTv8www.project-syndicate.org/css/style... https://www.project-syndicate.org/css/styles.min.css?v=tHx_zKUaEooV4cYyQnbVvI8_6IhtqKkvz3C52suXTv8 — 200 — 50.9 KiB — 69 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/favicon/manifest.jsonwww.project-syndicate.org/favicon/m... https://www.project-syndicate.org/favicon/manifest.json — 200 — 1.0 KiB — 411 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/54948d9326c5ff7801ec2094560c7dd1.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/54948d9326c5ff7801ec2094560c7dd1.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 78.4 KiB — 161 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/746e81c081b2a506fffdc14c127e5b27.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/746e81c081b2a506fffdc14c127e5b27.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 99.3 KiB — 103 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/bec80f6e77af9b412b478c14c6f45c2e.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/bec80f6e77af9b412b478c14c6f45c2e.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 109.5 KiB — 102 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/5e7d4080cf183402724539f1b21a57cd.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/5e7d4080cf183402724539f1b21a57cd.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 94.6 KiB — 132 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/df7b3af0c72e9a2e3163ebc5ae5694d5.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/df7b3af0c72e9a2e3163ebc5ae5694d5.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 128.4 KiB — 114 ms — h2https://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquery/3.7.1/jquery.min.jsajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquer... https://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquery/3.7.1/jquery.min.js — 200 — 30.4 KiB — 116 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/scripts/application.min.js?v=2bvm9WaCIHJtuJBpuDo6TcH9HjIGBjrjSuZ0tdFF_P8www.project-syndicate.org/scripts/a... https://www.project-syndicate.org/scripts/application.min.js?v=2bvm9WaCIHJtuJBpuDo6TcH9HjIGBjrjSuZ0tdFF_P8 — 200 — 159.8 KiB — 72 ms — h2https://assets.poool.fr/access.min.jsassets.poool.fr/access.min.js https://assets.poool.fr/access.min.js — 200 — 31.3 KiB — 101 ms — h2https://assets.poool.fr/audit.min.jsassets.poool.fr/audit.min.js https://assets.poool.fr/audit.min.js — 200 — 15.1 KiB — 96 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/f5d89e319df6fcbb807d94727f98b929.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/f5d89e319df6fcbb807d94727f98b929.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 60.1 KiB — 125 ms — h2https://data.flw.li/piwik/piwik.jsdata.flw.li/piwik/piwik.js https://data.flw.li/piwik/piwik.js — 200 — 21.6 KiB — 114 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/css/print.min.css?v=K59KUm2uuIRa1YCAwpEtbOVk2AdK-aVwwH1Ya90MYRMwww.project-syndicate.org/css/print... https://www.project-syndicate.org/css/print.min.css?v=K59KUm2uuIRa1YCAwpEtbOVk2AdK-aVwwH1Ya90MYRM — 200 — 5.1 KiB — 41 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/sprite.symbol.svgwww.project-syndicate.org/images/sp... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/sprite.symbol.svg — 200 — 7.4 KiB — 39 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/ps_logo.svgwww.project-syndicate.org/images/ps... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/ps_logo.svg — 200 — 1.1 KiB — 58 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/PScream.pngwww.project-syndicate.org/images/PS... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/PScream.png — 200 — 11.2 KiB — 60 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/PSblack.pngwww.project-syndicate.org/images/PS... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/PSblack.png — 200 — 9.4 KiB — 93 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/sprite.css.svg?v=ub0dxcuwww.project-syndicate.org/images/sp... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/sprite.css.svg?v=ub0dxcu — 200 — 9.0 KiB — 87 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/75e6ba362294f57645e6e4f3a099476a.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/75e6ba362294f57645e6e4f3a099476a.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 115.8 KiB — 62 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/b598b22bbd89d5d119fdb7654d48efba.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/b598b22bbd89d5d119fdb7654d48efba.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 46.0 KiB — 64 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/7a204d35b82eb950d5ce0f1646326f21.16-9-xlarge.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/7a204d35b82eb950d5ce0f1646326f21.16-9-xlarge.1.jpg — 200 — 144.2 KiB — 67 ms — h2https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=GTM-N6JW4VMwww.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=... https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id=GTM-N6JW4VM — 200 — 159.1 KiB — 184 ms — h2https://js.monitor.azure.com/scripts/b/ai.2.min.jsjs.monitor.azure.com/scripts/b/ai.2... https://js.monitor.azure.com/scripts/b/ai.2.min.js — 200 — 46.2 KiB — 138 ms — h2https://www1.project-syndicate.org/fwat.js?v=2026-4-22&s=1www1.project-syndicate.org/fwat.js?... https://www1.project-syndicate.org/fwat.js?v=2026-4-22&s=1 — 200 — 2.2 KiB — 53 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/ff97447608e6eeb1e7495525e2cfaebb.4-3-large.1.jpgwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/ff97447608e6eeb1e7495525e2cfaebb.4-3-large.1.jpg — 200 — 48.1 KiB — 45 ms — h2https://fonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Noto+Sans:400,700|Noto+Serif:400,400i,700,700i&display=swapfonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Not... https://fonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Noto+Sans:400,700|Noto+Serif:400,400i,700,700i&display=swap — 200 — 1.9 KiB — 95 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/PS_dot_inv.svgwww.project-syndicate.org/images/PS... https://www.project-syndicate.org/images/PS_dot_inv.svg — 200 — 2.1 KiB — 44 ms — h2https://cc.cdn.civiccomputing.com/9/cookieControl-9.x.min.jscc.cdn.civiccomputing.com/9/cookieC... https://cc.cdn.civiccomputing.com/9/cookieControl-9.x.min.js — 200 — 123.4 KiB — 165 ms — h3https://www.project-syndicate.org/member/info?returnUrl=%2F&_=1776888211186www.project-syndicate.org/member/in... https://www.project-syndicate.org/member/info?returnUrl=%2F&_=1776888211186 — 200 — 850 B — 213 ms — h2https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notosans/v42/o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ryti20_6n1iPHjc5a7du3mhPy0.woff2fonts.gstatic.com/s/notosans/v42/o-... https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notosans/v42/o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ryti20_6n1iPHjc5a7du3mhPy0.woff2 — 200 — 35.0 KiB — 73 ms — h3https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notoserif/v33/ga6daw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNVls-hfgvz8JcMofYTYf6D33WsNFH.woff2fonts.gstatic.com/s/notoserif/v33/g... https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notoserif/v33/ga6daw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNVls-hfgvz8JcMofYTYf6D33WsNFH.woff2 — 200 — 35.9 KiB — 65 ms — h3https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notosans/v42/o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ryti20_6n1iPHjc5aDdu3mhPy1Fig.woff2fonts.gstatic.com/s/notosans/v42/o-... https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notosans/v42/o-0bIpQlx3QUlC5A4PNB6Ryti20_6n1iPHjc5aDdu3mhPy1Fig.woff2 — 200 — 164.3 KiB — 95 ms — h3https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notoserif/v33/ga6faw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNfFIMZhhWnFTyNZIQD1-_P3_ct_NFiQg.woff2fonts.gstatic.com/s/notoserif/v33/g... https://fonts.gstatic.com/s/notoserif/v33/ga6faw1J5X9T9RW6j9bNfFIMZhhWnFTyNZIQD1-_P3_ct_NFiQg.woff2 — 200 — 46.9 KiB — 77 ms — h3https://static.hotjar.com/c/hotjar-6508368.js?sv=7static.hotjar.com/c/hotjar-6508368.... https://static.hotjar.com/c/hotjar-6508368.js?sv=7 — 200 — 6.2 KiB — 121 ms — h2https://www.clarity.ms/tag/tkf8ndlyjc?ref=gtmwww.clarity.ms/tag/tkf8ndlyjc?ref=g... https://www.clarity.ms/tag/tkf8ndlyjc?ref=gtm — 200 — 843 B — 122 ms — http/1.1https://apikeys.civiccomputing.com/c/v?d=www.project-syndicate.org&p=CookieControl%20Multi-Site&v=9&k=3599dc92d8c70f410da7b07e2c535858b485d897&format=jsonapikeys.civiccomputing.com/c/v?d=ww... https://apikeys.civiccomputing.com/c/v?d=www.project-syndicate.org&p=CookieControl%20Multi-Site&v=9&k=3599dc92d8c70f410da7b07e2c535858b485d897&format=json — 200 — 615 B — 94 ms — h3https://challenges.cloudflare.com/turnstile/v0/api.jschallenges.cloudflare.com/turnstile... https://challenges.cloudflare.com/turnstile/v0/api.js — 302 — 265 B — 83 ms — h3https://www.project-syndicate.org/comments/countswww.project-syndicate.org/comments/... https://www.project-syndicate.org/comments/counts — 200 — 1.1 KiB — 73 ms — h2https://www.project-syndicate.org/messaging/messageswww.project-syndicate.org/messaging... https://www.project-syndicate.org/messaging/messages — 200 — 1.3 KiB — 167 ms — h2https://script.hotjar.com/modules.6a0f3932cb1341a35c18.jsscript.hotjar.com/modules.6a0f3932c... https://script.hotjar.com/modules.6a0f3932cb1341a35c18.js — 200 — 56.6 KiB — 99 ms — h2https://scripts.clarity.ms/0.8.59/clarity.jsscripts.clarity.ms/0.8.59/clarity.j... https://scripts.clarity.ms/0.8.59/clarity.js — 200 — 26.2 KiB — 137 ms — h2https://challenges.cloudflare.com/turnstile/v0/b/0b8fb825cb67/api.jschallenges.cloudflare.com/turnstile... https://challenges.cloudflare.com/turnstile/v0/b/0b8fb825cb67/api.js — 200 — 17.4 KiB — 41 ms — h3https://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/turnstile/f/ov2/av0/rch/wmny9/0x4AAAAAACGQSarMbFu3coON/auto/fbE/new/normal?lang=autochallenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/c... https://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/turnstile/f/ov2/av0/rch/wmny9/0x4AAAAAACGQSarMbFu3coON/auto/fbE/new/normal?lang=auto — 200 — 97.1 KiB — 105 ms — h3https://www.project-syndicate.org/messaging/69df966470223f7927873c38/impresswww.project-syndicate.org/messaging... https://www.project-syndicate.org/messaging/69df966470223f7927873c38/impress — 200 — 1.4 KiB — 66 ms — h2https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/a6fdec76a1a94dc5be799068b0ab147e.pngwebapi.project-syndicate.org/librar... https://webapi.project-syndicate.org/library/a6fdec76a1a94dc5be799068b0ab147e.png — 200 — 235.2 KiB — 38 ms — h2https://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/cmg/1challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/c... https://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/cmg/1 — 200 — 208 B — 24 ms — h3https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-D51YBBGJVH&cx=c&gtm=4e64k0www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id... https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-D51YBBGJVH&cx=c&gtm=4e64k0 — 200 — 157.0 KiB — 50 ms — h2blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/09918b24-e5cd-4085-9b5f-535332441585challenges.cloudflare.com/09918b24-... blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/09918b24-e5cd-4085-9b5f-535332441585 — -1 — 0 B — 0 ms — https://www.project-syndicate.org/favicon/favicon.icowww.project-syndicate.org/favicon/f... https://www.project-syndicate.org/favicon/favicon.ico — 200 — 14.9 KiB — 35 ms — h2https://j.clarity.ms/collectj.clarity.ms/collect https://j.clarity.ms/collect — 204 — 289 B — 391 ms — http/1.1https://dc.services.visualstudio.com/v2/trackdc.services.visualstudio.com/v2/tra... https://dc.services.visualstudio.com/v2/track — 204 — 0 B — 206 ms — h2https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/destination?id=G-6MFMGV4H84&cx=c&gtm=4e64k0www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/desti... https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/destination?id=G-6MFMGV4H84&cx=c&gtm=4e64k0 — 200 — 171.1 KiB — 95 ms — h3https://region1.google-analytics.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-D51YBBGJVH&gtm=45je64k0v9180347702z8812328219za20gzb812328219zd812328219&_p=1776888211059&gcd=13l3l3l2l1l1&npa=1&dma_cps=a&dma=1&are=1&cid=805039610.1776888212&frm=0&pscdl=noapi&rcb=0&sr=412x823&uaa=&uab=64&uafvl=Chromium%3B147.0.7727.101%7CNot.A%252FBrand%3B8.0.0.0&uam=moto%20g%20power%20(2022)&uamb=1&uap=Android&uapv=11.0&uaw=0&ul=en-us&_s=1&tag_exp=0~115938465~115938468~117266401~117384405~117512542~118128923&sid=1776888211&sct=1&seg=0&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.project-syndicate.org%2F&dt=PS%20-%20The%20World%27s%20Opinion%20Page%20-%20Project%20Syndicate&en=page_view&_fv=1&_nsi=1&_ss=1&up.userSegment=anonymous&tfd=1190region1.google-analytics.com/g/coll... https://region1.google-analytics.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-D51YBBGJVH&gtm=45je64k0v9180347702z8812328219za20gzb812328219zd812328219&_p=1776888211059&gcd=13l3l3l2l1l1&npa=1&dma_cps=a&dma=1&are=1&cid=805039610.1776888212&frm=0&pscdl=noapi&rcb=0&sr=412x823&uaa=&uab=64&uafvl=Chromium%3B147.0.7727.101%7CNot.A%252FBrand%3B8.0.0.0&uam=moto%20g%20power%20(2022)&uamb=1&uap=Android&uapv=11.0&uaw=0&ul=en-us&_s=1&tag_exp=0~115938465~115938468~117266401~117384405~117512542~118128923&sid=1776888211&sct=1&seg=0&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.project-syndicate.org%2F&dt=PS%20-%20The%20World%27s%20Opinion%20Page%20-%20Project%20Syndicate&en=page_view&_fv=1&_nsi=1&_ss=1&up.userSegment=anonymous&tfd=1190 — 204 — 290 B — 227 ms — h2https://j.clarity.ms/collectj.clarity.ms/collect https://j.clarity.ms/collect — 204 — 289 B — 501 ms — http/1.1https://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/flow/ov1/2461874605:1776885205:fNEyEjrf0sS0M46VGAbg94TJe9j7x0rcIXeX7-8JsUc/9f073b7abd6b5038/TNYB.z.N5NMS2BErXtmfu_0n3ho7q8h79bUblhTctK8-1776888211-1.2.1.1-6sXXHPkDdNARukaSw7rGSH_TIFj1XfU0J2TU8.7wJn9WBeoY1zKuQRlNuWLCDCnychallenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/c... https://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/flow/ov1/2461874605:1776885205:fNEyEjrf0sS0M46VGAbg94TJe9j7x0rcIXeX7-8JsUc/9f073b7abd6b5038/TNYB.z.N5NMS2BErXtmfu_0n3ho7q8h79bUblhTctK8-1776888211-1.2.1.1-6sXXHPkDdNARukaSw7rGSH_TIFj1XfU0J2TU8.7wJn9WBeoY1zKuQRlNuWLCDCny — 200 — 280.5 KiB — 142 ms — h3https://region1.analytics.google.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-6MFMGV4H84&gtm=45je64k0v880267395z8812328219za20gzb812328219zd812328219&_p=1776888211059&_gaz=1&gcd=13l3lPl2l1l1&npa=1&dma_cps=a&dma=1&_eu=AAAAAGA&are=1&cid=805039610.1776888212&frm=0&pscdl=noapi&rcb=11&sr=412x823&uaa=&uab=64&uafvl=Chromium%3B147.0.7727.101%7CNot.A%252FBrand%3B8.0.0.0&uam=moto%20g%20power%20(2022)&uamb=1&uap=Android&uapv=11.0&uaw=0&ul=en-us&gaf=2&_s=1&tag_exp=0~115938465~115938468~117266400~117512542&sid=1776888211&sct=1&seg=0&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.project-syndicate.org%2F&dt=PS%20-%20The%20World%27s%20Opinion%20Page%20-%20Project%20Syndicate&en=page_view&_fv=1&_ss=1&ep.gtmEvent=gtm.load&tfd=1316region1.analytics.google.com/g/coll... https://region1.analytics.google.com/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-6MFMGV4H84&gtm=45je64k0v880267395z8812328219za20gzb812328219zd812328219&_p=1776888211059&_gaz=1&gcd=13l3lPl2l1l1&npa=1&dma_cps=a&dma=1&_eu=AAAAAGA&are=1&cid=805039610.1776888212&frm=0&pscdl=noapi&rcb=11&sr=412x823&uaa=&uab=64&uafvl=Chromium%3B147.0.7727.101%7CNot.A%252FBrand%3B8.0.0.0&uam=moto%20g%20power%20(2022)&uamb=1&uap=Android&uapv=11.0&uaw=0&ul=en-us&gaf=2&_s=1&tag_exp=0~115938465~115938468~117266400~117512542&sid=1776888211&sct=1&seg=0&dl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.project-syndicate.org%2F&dt=PS%20-%20The%20World%27s%20Opinion%20Page%20-%20Project%20Syndicate&en=page_view&_fv=1&_ss=1&ep.gtmEvent=gtm.load&tfd=1316 — 204 — 556 B — 99 ms — h2https://stats.g.doubleclick.net/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-6MFMGV4H84&cid=805039610.1776888212&gtm=45je64k0v880267395z8812328219za20gzb812328219zd812328219&rcb=11&aip=1&dma=1&dma_cps=a&gcd=13l3lPl2l1l1&npa=1&frm=0&tag_exp=0~115938465~115938468~117266400~117512542stats.g.doubleclick.net/g/collect?v... https://stats.g.doubleclick.net/g/collect?v=2&tid=G-6MFMGV4H84&cid=805039610.1776888212&gtm=45je64k0v880267395z8812328219za20gzb812328219zd812328219&rcb=11&aip=1&dma=1&dma_cps=a&gcd=13l3lPl2l1l1&npa=1&frm=0&tag_exp=0~115938465~115938468~117266400~117512542 — 204 — 565 B — 76 ms — h2https://www.google.es/ads/ga-audiences?v=1&t=sr&slf_rd=1&_r=4&tid=G-6MFMGV4H84&cid=805039610.1776888212&gtm=45je64k0v880267395z8812328219za20gzb812328219zd812328219&rcb=11&aip=1&dma=1&dma_cps=a&gcd=13l3lPl2l1l1&npa=1&frm=0&tag_exp=0~115938465~115938468~117266400~117512542&z=1607068572www.google.es/ads/ga-audiences?v=1&... https://www.google.es/ads/ga-audiences?v=1&t=sr&slf_rd=1&_r=4&tid=G-6MFMGV4H84&cid=805039610.1776888212&gtm=45je64k0v880267395z8812328219za20gzb812328219zd812328219&rcb=11&aip=1&dma=1&dma_cps=a&gcd=13l3lPl2l1l1&npa=1&frm=0&tag_exp=0~115938465~115938468~117266400~117512542&z=1607068572 — 200 — 408 B — 83 ms — h2https://dc.services.visualstudio.com/v2/trackdc.services.visualstudio.com/v2/tra... https://dc.services.visualstudio.com/v2/track — 200 — 200 B — 35 ms — h2blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-ae10-4f1a-80d2-f46c8f4211b5challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-... blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-ae10-4f1a-80d2-f46c8f4211b5 — 200 — -1 B — 53 ms — blobhttps://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/pat/9f073b7abd6b5038/1776888211968/b7134da3466e43179628ad7d03f4d6472356db613cbb6151c18a70ecb85e86c8/EWVGe77eAVEMivwchallenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/c... https://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/pat/9f073b7abd6b5038/1776888211968/b7134da3466e43179628ad7d03f4d6472356db613cbb6151c18a70ecb85e86c8/EWVGe77eAVEMivw — 401 — 1.7 KiB — 20 ms — h3blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-ae10-4f1a-80d2-f46c8f4211b5challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-... blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-ae10-4f1a-80d2-f46c8f4211b5 — 200 — -1 B — 8 ms — blobblob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-ae10-4f1a-80d2-f46c8f4211b5challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-... blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-ae10-4f1a-80d2-f46c8f4211b5 — 200 — -1 B — 23 ms — blobblob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-ae10-4f1a-80d2-f46c8f4211b5challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-... blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-ae10-4f1a-80d2-f46c8f4211b5 — 200 — -1 B — 19 ms — blobblob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-ae10-4f1a-80d2-f46c8f4211b5challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-... blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/f6603fd3-ae10-4f1a-80d2-f46c8f4211b5 — 200 — -1 B — 16 ms — blobhttps://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/d/9f073b7abd6b5038/1776888211969/XX_pQMIJVwpL1rMchallenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/c... https://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/d/9f073b7abd6b5038/1776888211969/XX_pQMIJVwpL1rM — 200 — 707 B — 21 ms — h3https://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/flow/ov1/2461874605:1776885205:fNEyEjrf0sS0M46VGAbg94TJe9j7x0rcIXeX7-8JsUc/9f073b7abd6b5038/TNYB.z.N5NMS2BErXtmfu_0n3ho7q8h79bUblhTctK8-1776888211-1.2.1.1-6sXXHPkDdNARukaSw7rGSH_TIFj1XfU0J2TU8.7wJn9WBeoY1zKuQRlNuWLCDCnychallenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/c... https://challenges.cloudflare.com/cdn-cgi/challenge-platform/h/b/flow/ov1/2461874605:1776885205:fNEyEjrf0sS0M46VGAbg94TJe9j7x0rcIXeX7-8JsUc/9f073b7abd6b5038/TNYB.z.N5NMS2BErXtmfu_0n3ho7q8h79bUblhTctK8-1776888211-1.2.1.1-6sXXHPkDdNARukaSw7rGSH_TIFj1XfU0J2TU8.7wJn9WBeoY1zKuQRlNuWLCDCny — 200 — 22.7 KiB — 45 ms — h3blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/a5953916-54fe-4ca3-97ce-cdf392045be0challenges.cloudflare.com/a5953916-... blob:https://challenges.cloudflare.com/a5953916-54fe-4ca3-97ce-cdf392045be0 — 200 — -1 B — 9 ms — blob
HTML JavaScript CSS Images Fonts XHR/Fetch Other
Third-Party Script Cost
Per-script blocking time, transfer cost, and cache headers
INFO
100% of JavaScript execution is third-party
First-party Third-party 2708ms · 985KB · €14/mo
www.project-syndicate.org
Other
Costly
Execution 655ms
Transfer 55 KB
Monthly Cost €3/mo
Unattributable
Other
Costly
Execution 305ms
Transfer 0 KB
Monthly Cost €2/mo
ajax.googleapis.com
Other
Costly
Execution 300ms
Transfer 30 KB
Monthly Cost €2/mo
Google Tag Manager
Tag Manager
Costly
Execution 226ms
Transfer 157 KB
Unused 41%
Monthly Cost €1/mo
Google Tag Manager
Tag Manager
Costly
Execution 222ms
Transfer 171 KB
Unused 42%
Monthly Cost €1/mo
Microsoft Clarity
Session Replay
Costly
Execution 207ms
Transfer 26 KB
Monthly Cost €1/mo
Google Tag Manager
Tag Manager
Optional
Execution 189ms
Transfer 159 KB
Unused 53%
Monthly Cost €1/mo
cc.cdn.civiccomputing.com
Other
Optional
Execution 188ms
Transfer 123 KB
Unused 47%
Monthly Cost €1/mo
www.project-syndicate.org
Other
Optional
Execution 164ms
Transfer 160 KB
Unused 75%
Monthly Cost €1/mo
Hotjar
Session Replay
Optional
Execution 147ms
Transfer 57 KB
Unused 67%
Monthly Cost €1/mo
js.monitor.azure.com
Other
Optional
Execution 107ms
Transfer 46 KB
Monthly Cost €1/mo

These scripts may cost more than they're worth

  • www.project-syndicate.org adds 655ms and costs ~€3/month
  • Unattributable adds 305ms and costs ~€2/month
  • ajax.googleapis.com adds 300ms and costs ~€2/month
  • Google Tag Manager adds 226ms and costs ~€1/month
  • Google Tag Manager adds 222ms and costs ~€1/month
  • Microsoft Clarity adds 207ms and costs ~€1/month

100% of JavaScript execution time is spent on third-party scripts. Consider auditing which scripts are essential.

Why this matters

When third-party JS execution time exceeds your own, performance gains from frontend work are capped by code you don't own.

Learn more ▾

Every millisecond of third-party JS competes with your own for main-thread time. If their share is bigger than yours, optimization on your code base barely moves the needle. Audit, defer, or remove third-parties before further frontend optimization. Use Lighthouse's third-party audit to identify the worst offenders.

Source: web.dev

www.project-syndicate.org takes 655ms of CPU time. Consider loading it asynchronously or replacing it with a lighter alternative.

Why this matters

This script has high main-thread execution time — optimize hot paths or defer.

Source: web.dev

Unattributable takes 305ms of CPU time. Consider loading it asynchronously or replacing it with a lighter alternative.

Why this matters

This script has high main-thread execution time — optimize hot paths or defer.

Source: web.dev

ajax.googleapis.com takes 300ms of CPU time. Consider loading it asynchronously or replacing it with a lighter alternative.

Why this matters

This script has high main-thread execution time — optimize hot paths or defer.

Source: web.dev

Google Tag Manager takes 226ms of CPU time. Consider loading it asynchronously or replacing it with a lighter alternative.

Why this matters

This script has high main-thread execution time — optimize hot paths or defer.

Source: web.dev

Google Tag Manager takes 222ms of CPU time. Consider loading it asynchronously or replacing it with a lighter alternative.

Why this matters

This script has high main-thread execution time — optimize hot paths or defer.

Source: web.dev

Microsoft Clarity takes 207ms of CPU time. Consider loading it asynchronously or replacing it with a lighter alternative.

Why this matters

This script has high main-thread execution time — optimize hot paths or defer.

Source: web.dev

53% of Google Tag Manager's code is unused. The script may be loading features you don't use.

Why this matters

Bundle has high unused-code ratio — tree-shaking and route-splitting recover the wasted bytes.

Source: web.dev

75% of www.project-syndicate.org's code is unused. The script may be loading features you don't use.

Why this matters

Bundle has high unused-code ratio — tree-shaking and route-splitting recover the wasted bytes.

Source: web.dev

67% of Hotjar's code is unused. The script may be loading features you don't use.

Why this matters

Bundle has high unused-code ratio — tree-shaking and route-splitting recover the wasted bytes.

Source: web.dev

How third-party costs are calculated

All checks on this page are automated. Results are estimates - run targeted manual reviews when the score affects a release decision.

Send Feedback